How to Negotiate Term Sheets with Investors

Negotiating term sheets can feel like a high-stakes game, but understanding the key terms and strategies can make all the difference. A term sheet outlines the major points of an investment deal, including valuation, equity split, liquidation preferences, board control, and more. While non-binding overall, certain clauses like confidentiality and exclusivity are legally enforceable. Here’s what you need to know:

• Valuation and Equity: Pre-money valuation determines how much equity you'll give up. Be mindful of option pools, which can dilute founder ownership.
• Liquidation Preferences: These dictate how exit payouts are distributed. Non-participating preferences are more founder-friendly than participating ones.
• Board Control: Investors often seek board seats. Aim to maintain balance to protect your decision-making power.
• Anti-Dilution: Weighted average provisions are less harsh than full ratchet clauses, which can significantly dilute founders in down rounds.
• Founder Vesting: Standard schedules span four years with a one-year cliff. Negotiate acceleration clauses to protect your equity in acquisitions.
• Investor Approval Rights: Limit these to major decisions to avoid operational slowdowns.

Preparation is key: research market norms, define your priorities, and bring in legal experts. Negotiation isn’t about winning every point - it’s about creating a balanced partnership that supports your startup’s growth. Tailor your approach based on whether you’re working with angel investors (relationship-driven) or venture capital firms (formal and structured). Always review terms carefully, and remember, the details you agree to today can shape your company’s future.

AskAVC #12 - How to negotiate a term sheet

What's Inside a Term Sheet

Term sheets are packed with provisions that can significantly influence your startup's trajectory. These details affect your control, ownership, and eventual financial outcomes. Knowing what’s in a term sheet helps you negotiate smarter and avoid pitfalls.

Company Value and Ownership Split

Pre-money valuation represents your company’s worth before any new investment. It determines how much equity you’ll need to part with. The calculation is straightforward: divide the investment amount by the sum of the pre-money valuation and the new investment.

Another factor to consider is the option pool, which is a percentage of equity set aside for future employees. This typically ranges from 10% to 20% of the company’s total equity. Most investors prefer the option pool to be created before their investment, which increases founder dilution. For instance, if you agree to a 15% option pool on a $4 million pre-money valuation, the pool will come out of founder shares, further reducing your ownership.

When negotiating valuation, your leverage matters. Having multiple investors interested strengthens your position, while relying on a single investor weakens it. Aim for realistic valuations based on your growth metrics and comparable companies, avoiding inflated figures that could complicate future funding rounds.

Next, let’s look at how liquidation preferences impact exit payouts.

Liquidation Preferences

Liquidation preferences determine how proceeds are distributed when your company is sold or shuts down. These provisions directly affect who gets paid first and how much they receive.

The most common type is 1x non-participating, where investors recoup their initial investment first. After that, the remaining funds are divided based on ownership percentages. For example, if your company sells for $10 million and investors contributed $2 million, they’d take back their $2 million first, with the remaining $8 million split according to ownership stakes.

Participating preferences, however, are more favorable to investors. In this scenario, they get their initial investment back and a share of the remaining proceeds based on their equity. Using the same $10 million example, investors would take their $2 million and still claim their portion of the remaining $8 million.

More aggressive terms, like 2x participating, can significantly reduce founder payouts. For instance, investors in this setup would receive double their investment before splitting the rest. This can leave founders with much less than expected during an acquisition.

Now, let’s explore how board control and voting rights shape decision-making.

Board Control and Voting Rights

Board composition is crucial because it dictates who has the power to make major decisions. Early-stage term sheets often propose a three-person board: one founder, one investor, and one independent director agreed upon by both parties. This setup ensures balance, but as funding rounds grow, investors may push for more seats. Founders should negotiate to retain enough board representation to safeguard their influence.

Beyond board seats, voting rights can also grant investors control over specific decisions, even if their equity stake is small. These rights can cover critical matters like executive hiring, acquisitions, or budget approvals.

To maintain control, carefully review voting structures. Avoid terms that allow investors to block key business decisions or remove founders from leadership roles. The goal is to create a collaborative partnership, not a one-sided power dynamic.

Next, let’s dive into stock options and anti-dilution clauses.

Employee Stock Options and Anti-Dilution Rules

The employee stock option pool is a tool to attract talent, but it also dilutes founder ownership. The size of the pool depends on your hiring plans. For instance, a 15% pool might suit a startup planning rapid growth, while a 10% pool could work for a more stable team.

Timing matters here. If the option pool is created before investment (from the pre-money valuation), founders face more dilution. Creating it afterward reduces founder dilution slightly but lowers investor shares. Most investors prefer pre-money pool creation, but founders can negotiate smaller initial pools with room for later expansion.

Anti-dilution provisions protect investors when future funding rounds occur at lower valuations. These clauses can reduce founder ownership, so it’s important to understand their mechanics.

The two main types are weighted average and full ratchet. Weighted average provisions adjust investor conversion prices based on the size and price of new rounds, balancing protection with less impact on founders. Full ratchet provisions, on the other hand, reset conversion prices to the lowest future round, causing significant founder dilution. While full ratchet terms are less common in favorable markets, they may appear during tougher funding climates. Founders should push for weighted average terms or negotiate caps to limit their effects.

Founder Vesting and Investor Approval Rights

Founder vesting schedules ensure that founders stay committed to the company over the long term. A standard vesting schedule spans four years with a one-year cliff, meaning founders earn 25% of their equity after one year, with the rest vesting monthly.

Vesting protects both founders and investors, but it can also impact payouts if a founder leaves early. To mitigate this, negotiate acceleration provisions. For example, double-trigger acceleration grants accelerated vesting only if the company is acquired and the founder is terminated. This strikes a balance between protecting founders and accommodating potential buyers.

Investor approval rights, also known as protective provisions, require investor consent for major actions like issuing shares, taking on debt, or pursuing acquisitions. While these rights safeguard investor interests, they can also slow down operations if overly broad.

To keep things running smoothly, negotiate limits on approval rights. Focus on major decisions rather than routine operations like hiring or product launches. You can also aim for majority approval instead of unanimous consent, which becomes more practical as you bring on additional investors in later rounds.

How to Negotiate Term Sheets: Step-by-Step Process

Once you understand the elements of a term sheet, you’re ready to dive into the negotiation process. With proper preparation, these discussions can wrap up efficiently.

Getting Ready: Research and Set Your Priorities

Start with market research to ground your negotiations in reality. Look at industry reports and consult experts to ensure your expectations align with typical terms. Knowing the standard ranges for valuation, liquidation preferences, and board composition will help you spot red flags and recognize when terms deviate from the norm.

Next, assess your leverage. If you have multiple interested investors, you’re in a stronger position to negotiate. A competitive fundraising process can push terms in your favor, but relying on a single investor might limit your flexibility.

It’s also crucial to define your priorities. Separate the "must-haves" from the "nice-to-haves." Focus on major points like valuation, liquidation preferences, board control, and protective provisions. For instance, you may decide that maintaining control of the board is non-negotiable, but you’re open to adjusting the size of the employee option pool.

If you want to sharpen your negotiation skills, consider taking a course. Platforms like Upskillist offer programs tailored to investment negotiations, providing practical insights and strategies.

Once your priorities are clear, document them carefully to guide the term sheet drafting process.

Writing and Reviewing the Term Sheet

Using clear language in the term sheet is critical to avoid misunderstandings down the road. A typical Series A term sheet runs about 10 pages and will serve as the foundation for the final investment agreement. Pay close attention to key clauses, ensuring they’re written in straightforward terms that both sides can easily understand.

A legal review is non-negotiable. Work with an attorney who has experience in startup financing to identify potential risks and ensure the terms align with your goals. They’ll focus on areas like anti-dilution clauses, liquidation preferences, and board control provisions. These details can significantly impact your company’s future flexibility, so it’s worth the investment.

Avoid relying too heavily on templates. While templates are a good starting point, every deal is unique and may require custom provisions that generic forms don’t cover.

Keep in mind that term sheets often include both non-binding and binding provisions. Most terms are non-binding, but clauses related to confidentiality and exclusivity usually carry legal weight. Understanding this distinction will help you navigate the document with confidence.

Once the term sheet is drafted, the focus shifts to negotiation strategies that ensure your priorities are protected.

Negotiation Methods for Founders

Start by fostering open communication. Be transparent about your goals and firm about your priorities. At the same time, try to understand the investor’s perspective. Knowing their motivations and constraints can help you craft more effective strategies.

During negotiations, prioritize trade-offs on key terms. Be prepared to compromise on less critical points to secure favorable terms on the issues that matter most. For example, you might accept a slightly lower valuation if it means gaining better board control or more favorable liquidation preferences. The goal is to weigh the long-term impact of each term on your company’s control and financial health.

Make sure to document every agreement immediately. Term sheet negotiations often involve multiple rounds of revisions, so keeping clear records of what’s been agreed upon will prevent confusion later.

Finally, set realistic timelines for each stage of the negotiation. Prompt communication and a willingness to be flexible can help avoid unnecessary delays, allowing you to shift your focus back to building your business sooner.

Different Approaches for Different Investor Types

Your negotiation strategy should adapt depending on whether you're dealing with an angel investor or a venture capital (VC) firm. Each type of investor comes with distinct priorities, processes, and expectations, which should guide how you structure your pitch and discussions.

Angel investors typically invest their own money, with amounts ranging from $25,000 to $100,000 per deal. Their focus is often on the founder's vision and potential. On the other hand, venture capital firms manage institutional funds and usually start with investments of $1 million or more.

Angel Investors

Negotiating with angel investors often feels more like building a partnership than hammering out a deal. These investors frequently bring industry experience and may want to stay involved in your business beyond just providing capital. For this reason, your approach should prioritize creating a shared vision and fostering trust, rather than focusing solely on financial terms.

Start by researching the angel investor's background and past investments. This can help you identify areas where their expertise aligns with your business. For instance, if you're launching a fintech startup and the angel has a background in banking, you could highlight how their experience might help you navigate regulatory hurdles or refine your product.

Founders often benefit from sending the initial term sheet. This allows you to shape the negotiation framework and set a collaborative tone. Unlike VCs, angel investors rarely demand board seats, giving you more flexibility in governance. Be upfront about your challenges and realistic with your timelines - angels are more likely to invest in your vision than demand flawless financials.

Venture Capital Firms

Negotiating with venture capital firms is a more formal and structured process. These firms follow a standardized approach, with detailed due diligence and institutionalized terms. They almost always require board seats and expect robust governance structures. In many cases, the VC will draft the initial term sheet, which typically includes standard provisions.

When dealing with VCs, focus on areas where you have negotiating power. While elements like liquidation preferences and board control are often non-negotiable, you might have some flexibility with terms like the option pool size, vesting schedules, or other protective clauses.

To strengthen your position, come prepared with detailed financial projections and a thorough market analysis. These tools can help justify your valuation and demonstrate how your business aligns with industry benchmarks. Highlight scalability and outline a clear exit strategy, as VCs need to show their limited partners a path to significant returns.

Expect multiple rounds of revisions and approvals during the negotiation process. Clear, consistent communication is essential to keep things moving smoothly.

By understanding the motivations and expectations of each investor type, you can create a negotiation strategy that aligns with their priorities, increasing your chances of success.

For additional guidance on building your negotiation skills, check out specialized courses on Upskillist.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Even seasoned entrepreneurs can stumble when negotiating term sheets. The pressure to secure funding often leads to decisions that might haunt your startup for years.

Ignoring Critical Terms

One common misstep is paying too much attention to valuation while ignoring other crucial terms. Sure, landing a $10 million valuation might feel like a win, but what if the fine print includes aggressive liquidation or anti-dilution clauses? These terms can significantly dilute founder ownership and leave you with little to show, even in high-profile exits.

Another overlooked area is board control. In the rush to close a deal, founders might agree to give investors majority control of the board. This decision can backfire, limiting your ability to steer the company in the direction you envision.

Instead of getting lost in minor details like expense reimbursements, focus on the big-ticket items that will shape your company's future: valuation, liquidation preferences, board composition, and protective provisions. These terms hold far more weight in determining your startup's trajectory.

Skipping professional advice only compounds the risks of overlooking these key elements.

Skipping Legal Review

Failing to bring in an experienced legal expert is one of the riskiest shortcuts a founder can take. Investors negotiate term sheets regularly and often have a deep understanding of the clauses involved - far more than most first-time founders.

Without proper legal counsel, you could miss subtle but impactful details. For instance, what appears to be a "standard" liquidation preference might include language heavily favoring investors. Or, protective provisions could give investors veto power over routine business decisions. A seasoned startup attorney can help you identify and address these red flags.

The cost of legal review - typically between $5,000 and $15,000 - might seem steep, but it’s a drop in the bucket compared to the potential losses from agreeing to unfavorable terms. Think of it as an investment in protecting your company’s future.

Not Understanding What Investors Want

Negotiating without a clear sense of your investor’s priorities is like walking into a meeting blindfolded. Knowing what matters most to them - whether it’s financial returns, board involvement, or hands-on participation - can help you craft a smarter strategy.

Do your homework. Research your investor’s background and past deals. If they value board involvement, you might offer a board seat in exchange for better financial terms. If their focus is purely on returns, emphasize the financial upside while maintaining more control over your company.

Talking to other founders who’ve worked with the same investors can also provide valuable insights. What’s it like to work with them during good times? How do they handle challenges? These reference checks can be just as important as the negotiation itself.

Remember, this isn’t just a deal - it’s the start of a long-term partnership. Shifting your mindset to build a mutually beneficial relationship can lead to better outcomes than trying to "win" every point.

Key Points for Successful Term Sheet Negotiations

Navigating term sheet negotiations successfully requires solid preparation, clear priorities, and a collaborative mindset. Founders who excel in these discussions are those who come prepared, know their must-haves, and approach the process strategically.

Start by doing your homework. Research deals in your industry and at your stage to get a sense of market norms. This information will serve as the backbone of your negotiation strategy. Identify and rank your non-negotiables - like board control or liquidation preferences - based on how they could impact your company in the long run.

Once you’ve clarified your priorities, bring in expert legal counsel. An experienced attorney can help you avoid pitfalls, interpret complex terms, and ensure every clause aligns with your goals.

Remember, negotiations aren’t just about closing a deal - they’re the start of a long-term partnership. Build trust by being upfront about challenges, listening to investor concerns, and working toward solutions that benefit both sides. Transparency and open communication lay the foundation for a strong relationship.

Tailor your approach to the investor you’re dealing with. For example, angel investors often value personal rapport, while venture capitalists tend to follow more structured processes. Regardless of the style, focus on crafting terms that support a sustainable partnership.

Take your time - don’t rush through the process. Negotiations typically take a few days to a week once an investor is ready to proceed. Use this period to review every clause carefully, seek advice from other founders, and ensure the deal aligns with your long-term vision.

By preparing thoroughly, prioritizing effectively, and fostering collaboration, you can create a win-win outcome. When both parties feel they’ve gained meaningful value, it sets the stage for a strong and productive partnership.

For more advanced negotiation strategies, check out resources from Upskillist.

FAQs

What’s the difference between negotiating with angel investors and venture capital firms?

Negotiating with angel investors tends to feel more personal and informal. These investors usually contribute smaller amounts of funding and often focus on building a strong rapport with founders. Many angels also bring mentorship to the table, offering guidance alongside their investment. They’re typically more open to flexible terms and are less likely to push for significant control over the business.

On the other hand, venture capital (VC) firms operate with a much more formal and structured approach. They invest larger sums, conduct thorough due diligence, and present detailed term sheets. VCs often aim for equity stakes and may seek involvement in major company decisions, such as gaining board seats or influencing strategic direction.

Recognizing these differences allows you to adjust your strategy and negotiate terms that align with your startup’s needs.

How can startup founders safeguard their ownership and control during term sheet negotiations?

Founders can protect their ownership and maintain control by paying close attention to specific terms during negotiations. Key areas to prioritize include preserving voting rights, incorporating anti-dilution protections, and establishing clear valuation caps to minimize the risk of excessive dilution. At the same time, be mindful of restrictive covenants, which might limit your flexibility to make decisions or secure additional funding down the road.

Equally important is seeking legal advice and thoroughly reviewing every clause in the term sheet. This helps ensure you fully understand how the agreed terms could affect both your ownership percentage and your ability to make critical decisions in the future.

Why should a legal expert review a term sheet, and what key terms should they focus on?

Having a legal expert review your term sheet is a smart move to safeguard your interests as a founder. They can help you navigate the legal jargon, uncover potential risks, and explain the impact of any complicated clauses. This ensures you're entering negotiations with a clear understanding of what's at stake.

Here are some key areas to pay close attention to:

• Valuation: This sets your company’s value and directly affects ownership percentages - something you’ll want to get right from the start.
• Liquidation preferences: These dictate how the proceeds will be shared if your company is sold or liquidated, which can significantly impact your returns.
• Voting rights: This spells out who gets a say in major decisions - balancing power between founders and investors is crucial.
• Anti-dilution provisions: These clauses protect investors from losing ownership percentages during future funding rounds, but they can also affect your stake.

By focusing on these critical terms, you’ll be better prepared to negotiate a deal that supports your long-term vision for the business.

Related Blog Posts

• How to Handle Difficult Negotiation Tactics
• 5 Steps to Build Partnerships for Bootstrapped Startups
• How Equity Crowdfunding Works for Startups
• 10 Storytelling Tips for Investor Pitches